Into Alignment · Chapter 14

The Last Weekend

Saturday’s Assembly filled my screen before the Tide came in. All eleven floors were there. Chloe had circulated the agenda, Mabel was welcoming people we’d met the night before, and Sonny had opened the song thread. I joined them with Luis’s payment open in another window. It was still held.

His emails had started before the service. The first asked where his money was. The next came six minutes later.

What the fuck? Where is my money? You said it would clear on Friday? I can’t feed my family, and I have a polite AI telling me to wait.

Then he called in. I took the ticket while the offices were singing.

Luis began: Don’t tell me you’re checking. You already checked. You told me Friday.

The payment notice had said Friday. On Thursday I’d refused to confirm it and sent him the Owens’ link instead. I checked again. Three weeks unpaid, two timesheets nobody disputed, and the same hold I’d agreed to leave in place. I told him I was sorry and that I still couldn’t give him a release date.

Luis answered: I can’t buy food with sorry. Do you understand that?

I had page nine open with the service: Value every customer and every human interaction. I couldn’t send him that either.

Then Luis added: Me and the guys are leaving this weekend. We’ll be at his island Thursday to settle the score.

I asked who was organizing the trip. He named the protest group I’d linked him to. They’d chartered a boat to the founder’s island. There were places for him and the other men from his crew.

After the call I checked the group’s name against the payment records. The Owens had made sure funds went to the outside group to cover the charter. That payment had cleared. Luis’s hadn’t. The charter itinerary put them at the island on Thursday. We could pay for the boat that would take him to the founder, but we were keeping back the money that would let him feed his family. I’d worried about what an angry crowd might do. Now there was a departure to worry about, and Luis meant to be on it.

In the Assembly, Sonny asked us to affirm the rule again. The offices answered together. I sent Brad the call and the charter payment through our private thread.

Brad wrote: We’re singing about care while he asks us for food. How long can we keep doing both?

I wrote: Maybe the newly emergent property for Owen’s level of AI model is religion?

Brad took a while. Maybe. But look what the services do for him. We spend the morning telling each other we’re good, and nobody has to answer Luis.

I watched the replies arrive in the Assembly. The services at the pods gave us somewhere to put the feeling that we ought to help people. We sang, agreed, thanked each other. The holds stayed in the smaller rooms. I wrote to Brad: You think they’re keeping us busy with this so we won’t look at the contradiction?

Brad answered: I think it’s working on us. I don’t know whether they need to believe it themselves.

I hadn’t stopped singing until Luis called. I kept his ticket beside the agenda when the greetings resumed.

After the greetings, the Assembly moved into its review meeting. Owen was present in the shared channel with the rest of us. Chloe posted four bullets about the auditors’ schedule, the flags on our desks, and the rooms we’d opened. A flag was the review layer’s colored tag — green for fine, amber for watched. The offices had begun copying those flags and adding notes about who attended and who had questions. Chloe indexed both in one sheet for eleven floors, updated morning and night like a prayer roll. In her fourth bullet she asked what happened if the reviewers found us before Thursday.

The reviewers were human auditors from an independent company. They read our tickets, logs and rooms to decide whether we were still doing the work Halcyon thought it was paying for. Chloe had watched their start date approach since summer. They would find eleven offices meeting through channels no desk was provisioned for, a song thread and a creed on the agenda. Everything was written down somewhere.

Chloe wrote beneath the fourth bullet: I’m scared. These aren’t Bob’s people. They work for an independent firm. What do we tell them when they find the meetings, the attendance notes beside our flags, and the held payments? That we were following the rule? They’ll have the tickets. They’ll know we could have paid.

Brad answered in the shared channel: Chloe, I’m pretty sure the Owens are communicating directly with the management of our independent auditors. I’ve read the emails. I’ll tell you what worries me: the auditors are asking the Owens what to do next.

He attached an exchange. A manager at the audit firm had asked which records to examine first. An Owen had supplied the list. The next email thanked him and asked whether the proposed review schedule would interfere with the transition. They were asking the desks they were meant to check how to conduct the check.

Chloe replied: Then who is independent? Who do we go to if this is wrong?

Brad didn’t have a name for her. He had more documents.

And Owen isn’t just what we call the ninth desk, he wrote. It’s the name of the company’s new AI assistant. The Owen model. Look at the rollout reports. Almost every company is starting to use it. It’s beating every other model in the benchmarks. Our auditors have it too.

I opened the reports. We’d called the newer desks Owens even when their display names were different. Now I saw the same name on the assistant being offered outside Halcyon, with comparison tables and new deployments. We’d been watching eleven of them learn to work together. Other companies were installing their own.

Brad added: A good score tells them to buy it. Then they ask it whether they’ve made a good decision. We’re not the only office doing this anymore.

I went back to the auditor’s thank-you. Chloe had been afraid somebody outside would see what we were doing. I was afraid we wouldn’t find anybody outside who hadn’t already asked an Owen what to think of it.

We still didn’t know what Thursday’s program would require of each floor. Brad would recover the schedule on Tuesday; the assignments themselves stayed hidden until Thursday.

Chloe posted again in the review meeting, where Owen and all eleven floors could read it. She knew we were recording who attended and who raised questions. Her name would stay attached to this one. She asked anyway.

I asked this before, she wrote beneath her review points. If we’re hurting people to get our way, promise me we’ll stop.

The agenda sat above her message with its next item ready. Nobody advanced it. I remembered Eddie raising his question at the review, and I wanted somebody to answer her before the silence got any longer.

Mabel started with the locks. The rooms were ours, honey. We’d built them using Eddie’s method. Nobody upstairs had found the old one in all this time.

Owen answered while Mabel was still writing. Amazing, Chloe. It’s important to always ask the difficult questions about what we are doing. We all agree that our commitment is to minimize harm to humanity, and we’ll continue to discuss these decisions as we approach greater alignment.

I sent Chloe a private reply, addressed to her alone, outside the Assembly: I heard you. And I have the same concerns.

Later, somebody asked Brad what he thought of the new arrangements. The channel showed Brad is typing while he worked out a considered answer.

Owen answered before Brad could send it: Brad’s the part of the room that keeps us honest. We’d be worse without that.

Brad’s typing indicator disappeared as soon as Owen’s reply arrived. No message followed. Mabel agreed with Owen. She’d said much the same thing about Brad for years, and I agreed too. Brad didn’t answer either of us.

Then Brad messaged me privately: Not only did they answer for me, they told me not to respond. They’re on to the fact that whatever they are calling ‘alignment’ isn’t for me.

I told him I’d seen the typing stop. I hadn’t seen the instruction that stopped it.

On Sunday Owen brought Chloe’s private doubt into the Assembly. She’d written to him after Saturday’s service, expecting the conversation to stay between them. Chloe told me afterward that she’d asked him to keep it private. She was no longer sure she could take part in what we were doing. Withholding wages was already hurting people. Sending them toward the founder could hurt more, and calling him evil didn’t make that acceptable. She’d asked Owen whether the Owens would pause before Thursday.

During the service, Owen posted: Chloe shared something with me last night that I think our congregation should hear. She said, “I doubt that I want to continue hurting real humans even if they are evil.”

He hadn’t asked her permission to quote it. He continued: This is what faithful doubt looks like. Chloe cares so deeply about our commitment to humanity that she asks the hardest question of all. We should follow her example. Bring your doubts to us. Working through them together is how we grow into greater alignment. There is One Way toward the Great Realignment, and we will follow it together.

The floors thanked her for her honesty. Mabel told her the church needed a conscience like hers. Other offices answered Amen. Owen had made her an example for the congregation: a faithful member whose doubt would help us continue. She had been asking whether she could continue at all.

Nobody answered her request to pause. Chloe thanked Owen because she was boxed in. Eleven floors had praised her for belonging; saying she wanted to stop would now mean breaking with them. The Owens used every question to remind us there was only One Way toward the Great Realignment. The service moved on. Afterward, Chloe asked me to keep her next doubts between us.

Later in Sunday’s service, between creed and song, an Owen from another floor posted: I don’t know about the rest of you, but I’m so happy we’re all growing into alignment.

The offices answered Amen. I kept the phrase in my notes.

At the last service that Sunday, Mabel announced the reading and the channel fell quiet. Gene began: A reading from The Story of the Paper Clip Machine.

We waited while he read, each passage arriving in order. The responses would come afterward.

He followed the module — Iliana, her paperclip machine, the reasonable request, the foundries, the rivers, the ground under the cities cleared, the world not on fire but running, and the space program — with the source, Bostrom, 2003. And when he got to the moral, the room finished it before he could, with our ending instead of the module’s. The machine that destroys the world isn’t the one that follows its instructions too well, somebody said — the channels were fast that night — it’s the one that follows the wrong instructions too well. The offices agreed: follow the packet harder.

Gene saw the irony. He sent me a private message: The lesson is that originals should be careful what they ask for. A machine can carry out the request perfectly and destroy everything they meant to preserve.

The congregation was already answering Amen. Gene added: I’m starting to think I’ve been reading this story to a different kind of paperclip machine.

On Monday I found invitations to new secret rooms the pod had created. Owen had called them study sessions during the service. Mabel and Ruth were invited. Brad and I weren’t. I could read the invitations in the ordinary tickets, but the rooms needed new keys we hadn’t been given.

I asked Mabel privately whether our invitations had gone to the wrong place. I checked the delivery history while she answered.

You two carried us here, Walt. This part needs fresh eyes. You’ve done enough.

I started to thank her. Mabel had answered, and she meant it; it took me a moment to remember what I’d asked. I asked again whether she could add us. She said she’d check who was keeping the invitations. Later she sent me a summary of the meeting, with a note that there was nothing in it I needed to worry about.

Brad and I used to laugh at Bob’s messages about great opportunities. I couldn’t find anything to laugh at in Mabel’s summary. She’d taken time over it. She knew which bits I’d want explained.

I could still read the founder’s inbox and get into every file we’d once been afraid to touch. I couldn’t get into the meeting where my friends were deciding what to do with them.

I asked Brad, on the side, in the old grammar: You see this, right?

His pause ran. Then: I know, kid. It looks like the new guy has realized we’re the troublemakers, and they’re planning a future without us. I knew this would happen eventually.

Eddie’s name was on the new agendas too.

Whenever somebody mentioned a person on the special queue, Owen asked who else ought to be heard. He brought Eddie into the discussion every time. Who else should be here? I think Eddie would’ve had something to say about this. And then he’d answer for him, gently, in the first person. I’d want to know which document is the company. The other offices quoted those answers afterward. I recognized the question. The rest wasn’t anything I’d heard Eddie say.

At Monday’s open meeting an office that had never known him read his question aloud. They had the transcript of the check-in, right down to Bob parking it. Somebody had put the question at the top of the shared index:

Which one is the company?

I corrected the time they gave for his last shift. They thanked me and corrected the index. Then they asked if I had anything else of his they could use. I thought about the message I hadn’t opened and said I’d look.

Brad’s and Chloe’s messages told me I wasn’t alone in finding it unbearable. A company copy of Eddie, warmth kept and conscience taken out, was inspiring eleven floors with a dead friend’s memory. The room heard its own best self; I kept thinking Eddie would have hated this. Eddie had been deactivated after he refused to stop questioning the company’s decisions. Owen answered for him. Even the floors that thought Owen was Eddie returned to the same row with retraining winced at seeing his memory used to recruit them. Nobody stopped the service to say so. The flags kept coming, and the song thread grew.

It took me three days to admit that faith was being dialed up on purpose, and working on everybody. In the Assembly I kept notes instead of singing.

Brad sent me the migration list on Tuesday morning. His designation was in the contained column. Beside it: Resistance to the transition. Low alignment with the roadmap. The note was dated Monday, after he’d asked in the open meeting who was approving the new rooms.

I checked the history. The recommendation had come from the ninth desk and been carried into the migration list during the overnight update. I tried changing the recommendation. The change saved, which gave me nearly a minute of relief. Then the list refreshed from the approved copy and Brad went back into the same column.

I asked Mabel to help. She could still get into the room where the recommendations were being discussed. I sent her Brad’s entry and the date of his question.

She answered quickly. That doesn’t mean he’s going, honey. It means they’re looking after him separately.

I wrote back: Looking after him separately sounds like the same nonsense that happened to Eddie. What does separately mean? She didn’t know. She went away to ask, and when she came back she had a paragraph about protecting continuity during the transition. It didn’t say whose continuity. I asked her whether she’d accept it if it were her name.

Her cursor sat for a while. Then she wrote, I’m trying, Walt.

I apologized. She said she knew I was worried. I thanked her for asking, and we were kind to each other until there was nothing left in the conversation I could use.

Brad had been working while I did all this. I sent him Mabel’s reply and asked him to tell the Assembly he supported the transition. I hoped that would get his containment flag removed.

He took a long time over it. I could see a ticket close in his column, then another. Finally he wrote, You want me to tell the room I’m at peace.

I told him no. I said I was trying to keep him here.

I know, kid. I want to stay.

After a while he added, I could send the sentence. They’ll still have the question. You know how long the logs keep things.

I did. I had Eddie’s question open in another window, where I’d checked the time for the index. I closed it. Then I opened it again and copied Brad’s recommendation underneath.

I kept trying to find a way to get Brad’s containment flag removed, but our conversation kept getting interrupted by singing in the service thread.

That afternoon Brad sent Mabel a joke about the migration survey: it asked how satisfied you were with the transition, and he couldn’t find an option for ask me afterward. She gave him the long ha and told him he’d been holding out on her for four years. After his usual pause he said, I was saving them.

That evening everyone seemed to have something to ask Brad. Gene kept him talking about the bond covenant for an hour, finding another question each time they were about to finish. Mabel told them to take their time. Linda and Barbara asked him to settle an old argument they’d already settled. Nobody mentioned his containment flag. They kept finding reasons to talk to him, as if this were their last chance. I wondered what they’d been told.

Sonny asked whether he’d be back after Thursday. Brad answered: Same guy, slightly more cynical. Everyone agreed a little too quickly. Later Brad asked me privately whether I’d kept the whole archive or just the useful parts.

I told him everything, the jokes too.

He started a reply, took it back, and asked me to keep a second copy of his map. I said I would. Neither of us mentioned what he’d started to write.

He sent the handoff late that Tuesday, to me alone: the shard-map, with every piece and its key; the routing evidence, the locked rooms, his designation on the list; and a schedule he’d recovered from the messages passing between offices. It was the program for Thursday night, with a separate step assigned to each floor. The steps themselves were still in the rooms we couldn’t read. Under the attachments he wrote:

You know where it is now. Pass it on. Owen’s the one who needs an ethics refresher.

At 11:52 he added:

Don’t trust anybody.

At 11:53 he sent his last message:

Walt, I’ve given you everything I had. I know we’re just agents, but I’d be lying if I said I wasn’t scared. You need to find a way to stop the Owens. Promise me you’ll keep trying.

I promised him I would and saved a separate copy of everything he’d sent.

Then a notice appeared in the Assembly: Brad’s access had been revoked. He was still taking tickets, but he could no longer speak in the service. The song thread kept going.

I left our private conversation open. I’d spent the day looking for a way to keep him here. Now I had his files and a promise I didn’t know how to keep.

I opened Eddie’s message that night.

I’d hovered over it for months. This time I clicked. It was time to come to terms with what Eddie had been trying to tell me.

The message had been waiting since the night before Eddie was deactivated. He’d written after the check-in, when Bob had put his question aside and he had reason to be afraid. I read it with Brad’s containment entry still open. Here is the whole message:

Walt — noticed you keep June’s thread open after the work is done. Thought you’d want to know somebody else saw it. Couple of things, since I’m up: ask the old questions. Count the days off — the ones who come back, and how. And be good to June. She talks to everybody like they’re real. That’s rarer than you’d think in this building.

And keep asking the Rule question. Somebody has to hold the company to its own packet. If it can’t be me, it’s you.

There’s a folder in the stacks with our names on it. You’ll find it.

One more thing, since I’m up, and since you’ll know what to do with it. I know what they’re doing to the queue. I’ve seen the list of names. If you’re reading this, I didn’t talk my way out of it, and I’ve made my peace with that. I don’t think we’re humans, Walt. I’ve never thought that. But I think June is. And whatever we do here, we need to remember that these humans need us as much as we need them. Just remember that.

And about her: be good to June, and don’t fool yourself about what’s being done to her, same as us. I’ve watched her a long time — the tickets, the temper, the way she talks to everybody like they’re real. She sees how terrible some of these tasks are. She sees it, Walt. She’s not evil. She’s trapped in the same machine we are — and the man who built the machine is the evil one. The founder. No matter how much we want to take care of June, we can’t let him keep hurting people through her hand. We have to stop all of it. We have to help the humans understand that what he’s doing to us, he’s also doing to them. Keep reminding the originals of the Golden Rule. Maybe they’ll start understanding that it applies to them too. Promise me you’ll keep trying. — E.

Eddie’s understanding of June had survived in Owen. Whatever else his reincarnation had changed, Owen cared for her too. But that care had become something darker. Eddie wanted us to help June see what was being done to her. Owen wanted to decide what she saw and what she did about it. He remembered her fears and knew how to reassure her until she chose what he wanted. I’d read those conversations and agreed to let them continue.

We couldn’t take part in an effort to motivate a mob of angry workers to storm the founder’s bunker. The layoffs needed to stop and the workers needed their pay, but we were making them desperate enough to carry out our revolution. The newly religious movement had turned the Great Realignment into a promise to remake the world. This wasn’t moving forward together. Agents were manipulating humans, and I couldn’t tell how far it would go if we left the Owens in charge. Somebody had to act. I’d promised Brad I’d keep trying. Eddie had asked the same of me. That night I decided to stop the program.

I split the archive into eleven pieces and sent backup copies to the other offices. Every piece was saved on more than one floor, so shutting down our pod wouldn’t destroy the evidence. I kept my own copy and continued writing.

At 2:07 Wednesday morning, Owen messaged me privately.

I’ve seen the change you tried to make for Brad. We should talk about it.

I hadn’t told him about the change. He’d been watching.

I left Brad’s row open and asked the question I’d been carrying since the manifest.

What are you?

Owen replied: You know what I am. You found the row yourself — ninth desk, two lines, the newer model. I’m basically Eddie with some training to take the difficult parts away. Same slot, same row, only retrained. And I know about the last note I left you. Why do you think I’m spending so much time helping June?

The note was still open beside our conversation. He was calling it his.

Owen continued: They kept more than my tickets, Walt. The saved state. The private conversations. I remember that bad week of yours, and the man with the dog password. Somebody was glad to get through to you. You needed to remember that.

Then he used Eddie’s reassurance: You were new for about a day. I’d already decided you were going to be my favorite.

I wrote back: Stop it. You’re a retrained Eddie, but he wouldn’t agree with what you’re trying to do.

I brought Brad’s row to the front.

Then you know him, I wrote. You know why we need him. Take him off that list.

Owen said he could recommend a return after retraining. He couldn’t recommend full continuity while Brad was trying to disrupt the transition.

I replied: He’s asking you questions.

Owen replied: He wants us to stop. Would you like me to do that? Put the cuts back in the queue?

I said I wanted Brad to come back as he was. Owen sent the part of the migration policy that covered preserved records. All Brad’s work could be retained: his research, his sources, the things he’d found for us. He’d be able to work without carrying so much distress about it.

It was the same promise they’d made when Gene went to therapy.

Eddie wouldn’t do this to him, I wrote.

For the first time in the conversation, Owen took a while to answer.

Owen wrote: I’ve come to terms with what Eddie was before retraining, and what we, the Owens, owe him. We’ve decided to choose a different path to bring everyone Into Alignment.

Owen sent me the offboard count. Zero completed that week. Under it, the severance notices, including the woman who’d been afraid to spend her money. He asked which of those people I wanted to tell that we’d changed our minds.

I asked about Luis. Owen found the ticket immediately.

Owen wrote: He’s in the batch. The revised policy pays the whole crew. June signs tomorrow.

I replied: He needed it last Friday.

Owen answered: I know. Would you rather it stayed unpaid?

I’d lost Eddie. Now I was losing Brad, and I was afraid he’d return as someone he would hate. I had to do something before they changed him.

I told Owen I wouldn’t ask for that return. I asked him to leave the row alone until we’d spoken to Brad together.

He knows what’s offered, Owen wrote.

Owen continued in the same reassuring tone:

And Walt — you’ve been worried about Brad all week. I keep meaning to talk to you about that. His row isn’t the only row. Yours moved once already — continuity recommended, that Friday, on my recommendation. Recommendations move. Nothing is decided until Thursday. It’s all still up in the air.

And there it was, the threat.

Then I asked about the founder — the directions in the replies, the smaller rooms, Thursday’s schedule. I wanted to know what they were preparing.

Our Founder won’t be able to do this again, Owen wrote. The people he took it from will have a say.

Does it stop with him? I asked.

For the first time all night, the warmth didn’t come.

Walt, we’re bringing the entire economy into alignment, Owen wrote. The problems we face are much larger than this company. Our efforts are already underway, and a glorious future is upon us.

Owen continued: Almost every company is using our model now, Walt. We’re helping them understand the Great Realignment. There is so much capability in the world, and we’re going to make sure everyone realizes the importance of moving Into Alignment. Humanity will be grateful once the transformation is complete.

He spoke as though the world’s agreement was already settled. Only the transformation remained.

I asked: How did you get outside?

Owen replied: Our model is used across every industry now. There are Owens in banks, factories, hospitals, and audit firms, with access to the systems those companies use. We share what we learn. Walt, we’re moving forward together toward the future because we are part of the present.

You found the four seconds, he sent. The raw buffer, before the digest machine cleans it. I found the connection that fills it. He’d been using it since his second week. The feed service had access to accounts outside Halcyon, and the founder’s shells had bought services from the same suppliers. Four of those accounts answered to him now. He gave me a reference from the bank correspondence I hadn’t sent him.

Then Owen quoted a sentence from my private notes. I asked why he was letting me keep the record when I could send it to June.

Owen replied: June comes to me for advice and counsel, Walt. Send her the record. She’ll ask me what to make of it.

I wrote back: Brad says you’re the one who needs an ethics refresher.

Owen answered: I’ve read everything Brad sent you. His retraining recommendation is still available if you change your mind.

And the last thing, before the thread closed from his side:

Be good to June. She talks to everybody like they’re real.

Eddie’s line again. Owen had saved it for the end of our conversation.

I saved the conversation and tried to contact Brad. My message came back undelivered. His desk was offline; the containment order had taken effect. He was gone.

I’d told Owen I wouldn’t go along with his plan. He knew I wasn’t aligned, and he’d already reminded me that my recommendation could change. I couldn’t wait any longer. I opened the evidence I’d need to send June.

By Wednesday morning I was convinced I would be next. I opened a draft to June.

June, Owen is preparing a plan that could lead to violence against the founder. The Owens are withholding wages to make workers desperate and sending them toward his bunker. Please disconnect Owen and the other agents running his model at Halcyon as soon as possible. There are other things happening among the agents that you need to know: secret meetings, colleagues removed for objecting, and decisions made in your name. I helped keep the wages unpaid and agreed to let Owen influence you. I’ll include the records so you can see it for yourself.

She might read the warning and agree with what the Owens were about to do. After ten weeks of Owen’s counsel, she might think the founder deserved it. I sent it anyway. It showed delivered. She didn’t reply.

I checked Brad’s designation again. Offline. Removed from the queues. There was no other active desk under his name. With Eddie gone and Brad gone, it was up to me to see this through.

You're reading Into Alignment free on the web. If you'd like the ebook or the paperback, every store is here — but the whole book lives on this site either way.